Feelings vs. Choice

“If ever I loved Thee, my Jesus, ‘tis now.”

–  Hymn by William R. Featherstone


The line struck me the other night, popping up unexpectedly in my head, because love is still a stark mystery to me, and because I know my love for Jesus is not what it used to be. It’s taken me back to an old debate: is love a feeling, or a choice?


Is it right that my love for Christ would fluctuate, never leaving entirely but existing in highs and lows in response to circumstances? It doesn’t sound right, does it? A verse came to mind: “He who is forgiven little, loves little.” (Luke 7:47) And I concluded that my lack of love could be from Elder Brother Syndrome (Luke 15:23-32). My gratitude for Christ’s forgiveness could be directly linked to how much I feel I’ve been forgiven, and although I’m not perfect, I have managed in my life to avoid a lot of the more obvious, more damaging sins.

The great equalizer to this line of thinking is to remember that whoever breaks one commandment is guilty of breaking them all (James 2:10), meaning that although we may have all sinned to varying degrees, we are all equally screwed. Being a Christian my whole life, I don’t know the kind of life that Jesus saved me from, saved me from having to go through, and damnation is something I can only understand in abstract ideas. I have nothing practical to look at and say, “This is how grateful I should be.”

On the contrary, for over a year now I’ve been in one of the darkest periods of my life. (I’m a technical person, and don’t like to over-dramatize things by saying, “This is the worst thing ever,” unless I mean it. Growing up, there were maybe two periods of my life darker than this.) And I’m not feeling the love.

Compounding this is the feeling that God is being inattentive and uncooperative. Letting things slip. Refusing easy prayers where I’m just asking for help carrying out His will, and receiving no such help. To put it in the closest human terms that I can conceptually relate to, I feel like I’m in a marriage with an emotionally distant spouse who refuses to work on the relationship. I’m trying and trying, but they won’t have any of it. This is not like the God that I’ve come to know. This is not the Jesus that I “married”. Theologically speaking, God is unchanging, but my present experiences disagree. What do I do with that?

There’s a number of easy answers. At least, they sound easy at first.

1: Suck it up, Wuss.

I can carry on as if everything’s fine, accept my lot in life, and declare that even the crap I’m going through is “good” and never complain again. That would turn me into a machine (I mean, more of a machine than I am now). It would be dishonest, and I would lose the ability to talk about anything authentically. It would be out of pious servitude, and yet I don’t think God would want that.

2: Conclude God was never real in the first place and carry on as if He doesn’t exist. This would also be dishonest (for me). I’ve seen too much. More importantly, I have felt His love. The fact that I don’t feel it now does not disqualify everything that’s happened before now.

3: Lash out at God because of what I’m going through. He obviously isn’t intending to take care of my needs, so through sin I can take care of my own needs and spit in God’s face at the same time.

That last one is the most appealing, and I have gone there from time to time, but I have not settled into that lifestyle.

Why not?

Well…because I still care about Him.

Sin hurts Him. Through some mysterious process I don’t fully understand, every sin I commit today has been laid on Christ two-thousand years ago, adding to His suffering. It hurts Him. And I don’t want to hurt my friend.

Does that seem childish? Maybe it is. Maybe it’s just because loyalty is such a big part of who I am. Maybe I’ve just been through too much suffering myself and just don’t like the idea of inflicting any amount of it on anyone, even someone I feel has deeply hurt me or even betrayed me. Is that how some married people feel after a while? Hurt and betrayed, yet in spite of that they still care?


“Love isn’t a decision, it’s a feeling.

If we could decide who we loved, it would be much simpler,

but much less magical.”

–  Mr. Twig

Who’s Mr. Twig? If you know then you simultaneously get a high-five along with my sympathy. If you don’t know, don’t worry, it just means you have better sense.

The Twig makes a good point here, but I don’t think it’s the whole story. Admiration, captivation, that kind of thing are all feelings. You can’t force yourself to feel those things. You can’t decide to feel those things. And if those feelings were never there then relationship wouldn’t work – just partnership.

But feelings fluctuate. Spring fades. Feelings alone won’t make a relationship last. So what do you do when feelings of love are no longer enough?


In the midst of my own struggles I’ve come to realize a new kind of faith is required. A new kind of love.

Fidelity is not a feeling, nor does it fluctuate because of circumstance. It is a decision. An act of love. Unconditional. Do I feel a love for God with all my heart? Honestly, not nearly as strong as I have in the past. Am I choosing with all my heart to act out of love for Him? Yes. Currently, that’s the best that I can offer.

I don’t presently feel like I can trust Him either, but in my daily life I’m still making decisions based on an act of trust. I’m choosing to trust, in spite of my feelings. I’m choosing to love when I don’t feel loved. I’m choosing faithfulness, though my heart tends to wander.


Some think the message that “God loves you” is irrelevant, because God loves everyone. It’s His job. If love was either a feeling or a decision, then yes, it would be less reassuring, but it isn’t just one or the other. It’s both. The atonement of Christ was an act, not a feeling. It was an act performed because God had promised salvation long beforehand, and God chooses faithfulness. That does not automatically mean that He loves you, the fact that He loves you is independent, based on the feelings of His own heart, and His feelings of love for each of His creations are unique and personal.

If God’s love for me was based solely on how He felt at the time, then I would worry about Him revoking my salvation whenever I pissed Him off. And if it was purely a decision because it’s His job, then it wouldn’t feel real to me, and I would worry that there isn’t anything about me to love. But God’s love for His people is both a feeling and a decision.

God’s decision to love us (to act with love) did not come on its own but was led on by His feelings of love for us. And my choice to remain with Him did not arrive on its own, but was made out of feelings of love for Him. If I had not seen God act in my life in the past, I would not have chosen fidelity. My choices would be based purely on the feelings of the moment. And the moment is quite dark. And the moment is often overwhelming. But the things I have experienced in the past assure me in the moment that there is also a future.


“Help me not forget in darkness

The things that I believed in light.”

–  Starfield

About benjaminfrog

Yo. I'm a 30-something Christian guy and published author with a love for gaming, fantasy and sci-fi. I blog about pop culture, living as a young Christian guy, and living with A.S.
This entry was posted in Personal, Spiritual and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Feelings vs. Choice

  1. benjaminfrog says:

    Mr. Twig is a character from South Park who served as a temporary replacement when Mr. Hat went missing. He’s a stick with a purple shirt and a French accent. Maybe now you can see why I’m just a little embarrassed for quoting him. -.-

  2. annasklar says:

    Hey Bro – I LOVE this post – your honesty and loyalty really shine through – thank you for sharing. Your decision to love and trust your God, even when He’s giving you the silent treatment reminds me of Christ on the cross – “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” He CHOSE to go there, peacefully even, when He could have called it quits anytime He wanted. And also reminds me of when Jesus was in the wilderness, and even when He was tempted by Satan himself (the supreme tempter of all tempters), He still CHOSE to follow God and God’s will for His life.
    There have been wilderness times in my life, times when God wasn’t saying much at all. During those times, I simply had to put one foot in front of the other and keep walking on the journey of faith. Usually it meant He was growing me and reshaping me in some way, usually there was blessing waited on the other side of the barren, silent wilderness.
    I look forward to seeing what God has for you on the other side… for now I will be praying for you as you keep walking…

  3. Bert Neutel says:

    You have shared a lot in this post, and it is very heartfelt. Reading this there were quick responses that came to mind, but each one was tempered in moments by your subsequent statements,

    I have no easy answers. I can share that I have been there. But that does not help. I was reading several Psalms in the last 2 weeks that perfectly capture this feeling that you express, and also others which show the Psalmist did find peace and assurance. (Psalm 13, 22 vs 23, Psalm 69, 77, 102, 130). I struggle reading Psalms because while so much is clear, much remains that I am not sure I understand. But in reading them, over and over again, I get the sense that He is steadfast and even when I cannot see Him in my life, He is there. One thing that came through to me when I went through Psalms this latest time was that this was not so much about me as it was about God and His creation. We are all part of that creation, and I need to see more than just myself and God. That was not the answer I was seeking, but it helped me.

    Love has feelings. But love is not based on feelings. The foundation of a commitment with God, Him to us, and us to Him, allows feelings to enrich and strengthen that commitment. Pastors and psychologists have said that feelings are neither right nor wrong, they just are.

    And time is subjective. We can measure it with a stop watch. But despite the measure of the clock our senses tell us differently. When we despair time is forever. When we want euphoria to be without end, it flashes by. At this point in my life I know that I have felt supported and embraced by my Father’s love for most of my life, far more than 60 or 70 or even 80% of it. Yet in my despair it feels like the opposite.

    I will continue to pray as I have for you. And others will too. This struggle of yours is not easy, it is draining and it leaches joy.

    • benjaminfrog says:

      It does help to know that others have been through these seasons. It reminds me of the odds of coming through. Though I don’t like the thought of others having to go through it at the time. And the fact is if I compare what I’m going through to what many others are going through then my own pain seems like nothing – and yet knowing that doesn’t remove the pain. If only logic had that power.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s